Everything fit together snugly and had nothing by way of blemishes or imperfections, no complaint to be had about the design or construction. Unfortunately I walked into a door and dropped the thing breaking the pipe. Thankfully the ash catcher survived so if I decide another purchase is worth it to me I still have that going. Sure am glad they included the Sherlock with orders in March or i'd be outta luck completely right now. Keep up the stellar work!