I use this with a 16" Beaker Tree Perc and resin buildup has been reduced by 95% with the Phoenix. Due to the design of this ash catcher, the durability leaves a bit to be desired. For reference, the Upline ash catcher's glass is about 1.5X thicker thank the Phoenix. Other than that, the Phoenix is no brainer. Oh yea, the Phoenix comes with an Octabowl (which sells separately for about $15) which brings the cost of the ash catcher itself to about $35. Hope this review is helpful. Be well and have a peaceful day.